About Us

Welcome to Ponytails, your go-to candy store in the heart of Chincoteague Island!

Family-owned since 1965, we pride in our rich history and are excited to have undergone new ownership in 2019. Home to the original Ponytails taffy, we have rebranded our store, introducing new and improved flavors, trending treats, and so much more while preserving the beloved experience and iconic tastes that our customers have cherished for decades. Dive into our delightful selection of sweets and indulge in a  journey that continues to bring joy to everyone!